First Dance Songs That Aren’t Overplayed… But Are Just as Magical
Perfectly Unexpected: First Dance Songs That Aren’t Overplayed (But Are Just as Magical)
Your first dance should feel like you—not like a wedding playlist on repeat. Sure, classics like At Last and Perfect are beautiful, but if you want a song that feels a little fresher, a little less expected, and still 100% goosebump-worthy, we’ve got you covered.
Here are ten unique and swoon-worthy first dance songs that will set the mood without feeling overplayed.
1. “Perfect for Me” – Bradley Marshall
Soft, heartfelt, and packed with raw emotion, this song feels like an intimate love letter put to music. If you’re looking for lyrics that will have guests reaching for tissues, this one’s for you.
2. “Speechless” – James TW
A song that perfectly captures that “I-can’t-believe-I’m-marrying-you” moment. James TW brings that soulful, stripped-down magic, making this an unforgettable choice for a deeply personal first dance.
3. “Beyond” – Leon Bridges
If you love a little retro soul with your romance, Beyond is a smooth, dreamy, and deeply romantic pick. It’s the kind of song that makes you sway a little slower and hold each other a little tighter.
4. “First Day of My Life” – Bright Eyes
For the indie lovers—this song is pure, sweet simplicity. The lyrics feel like a handwritten love note, and it’s the perfect choice for a couple who wants a laid-back, heartfelt first dance.
5. “The Wine We Drink” – Drew Holcomb & The Neighbors
Warm, folksy, and real—this song is all about celebrating the small, beautiful moments in love. It’s not just about the big milestones but the everyday magic that makes a relationship special.
6. “All Your’n” – Tyler Childers
If your love story is a little rugged, a little country, and a whole lot of soul, this song is it. Earthy, poetic, and deeply romantic, this track brings an effortless and organic beauty to a first dance.
7. “It Takes a Woman” – Chris Stapleton
Chris Stapleton never misses when it comes to love songs, and this one is no exception. It’s a powerful tribute to the kind of love that changes everything—perfect for a couple that wants something sentimental yet strong.
8. “Real Love Baby” – Father John Misty
A little quirky, and vintage—this song is for the couple that wants a dance that feels joyful, effortless, and full of personality.
9. “Autumn Love” – Death Cab for Cutie
Romantic, nostalgic, and beautifully cinematic. If you and your partner love a good indie moment and want something that feels like a scene from a movie, Autumn Love is a dreamy and unexpected pick.
10. “Heavenly” – Grant Lee Phillips
A song that feels exactly like falling in love. Soft, sweeping, and timeless, Heavenly is the perfect backdrop for a dance that feels like floating.
10. “Ordinary ” – Alex Warren
Love isn’t about grand gestures or perfect fairytales—it’s about finding someone who makes even the ordinary feel extraordinary. This song captures that feeling beautifully, making it a heartfelt and modern first dance choice.
Make It Your Own
The first dance is one of those wedding moments where you get to pause, breathe, and soak it all in. So whether you go for something romantic, indie, soulful, or a little country, pick a song that makes you feel something.
And if none of these are quite right? Just remember—whatever song you choose, it’s going to be perfect because it’s yours. Need some inspiration? Listen to this blog curated playlist on Spotify here.
From the desk of Megan Craig, Strathmere Wedding & Sales Manager
